Response to the article Nine reasons why we should support Aadhaar
The article by Sri . Bhamy V Shenoy titled “Nine
reasons why we should support Aadhaar” yet another example of how
unfounded the arguments for AADHAAR are. The author criticizes the media
which has now began to come out with studied opinions on the project.
He also finds fault with the NGOs that are reluctant to support Aadhaar
which will solve the problems of corruption and leakages in welfare
schemes that they are confronted with in their day to day activities.
Further he accuses the Parliament’s Standing Committee on Finance (SCoF)
of throwing the baby out with bath water. He is right in pointing out
that the SCoF has not advanced any new arguments or rationale to oppose
aadhaar. But is does not mean that the arguments are irrelevant. Rather
it reveals the failure of Unique Identification Authority of India
(UIDAI) in addressing the concerns and defending the project though they
had a prior knowledge of the questionnaire they would need to answer.
It was the nature of the project form the very beginning shrouded in a
fog of silence, impudence, ignorance and opacity.
On the Dissent notes in SCoF Report.
The
author who complaints about the media of selectively quoting the SCoF
report and ignoring the dissent note should read the report once. The
report in its concluding section (observations / recommendations) lists
out its opinions clearly and nowhere in that we can find even a single
line justifying the Project. The real criticism should have been on the
unsuspecting complaisance the media shown in initial stages of the
project by ignoring the concerns raised by eminent personalities.
It
also seems that the author has no idea what the dissenting MPs (only 3
of the 34 member committee) wrote in their notes of dissent. Let’s
examine one by one.
1. Rashid Salvi, MP
He does not have any reservations on all the 12 paragraphs that raises concerns on the UID but suggests “deleting” the 13th and concluding paragraph that asks the government to come forth with a new legislation, citing no reasons.
2. Prem Das Rai, MP
The dissent note reads:
“At
the outset I do not believe that the bill should be rejected in the
manner it has been. Since I have been inducted into the Committee
recently I do not have the inputs that went in when the stakeholders and
other Government departments were giving witness. I also do not know
whether we gave enough time to the UID implementers to give evidence and
present their point of view.”
the thing is clear, he dissented because of “ignorance”.
3. Manicka Tagore, MP
Manicka
tagore could not attend the meeting on adoption on draft report and
citing no arguments to counter the observations in the report, simply
reiterates the claims by the UIDAI about plugging leakages and
corruption in welfare schemes expresses dissent.
Now,
Mr. Shenoy what is there in these dissent notes worthwhile to discuss?
Reiterating the claims that failed to convince the SCoF won’t justify
AADHAAR. Lets take them one by one:
Claims
|
Reality
|
Aadhaar can plug massive misuse of subsidy
|
· Corruption
and leakages in welfare schemes like PDS occur not mainly from ghost
IDs but from structural, operational and administrative inadequacies.
· Much
of the diversion takes place not at the fair price shops with bogus
ration-cards but at upper layers of supply chain. UID cannot solve
this. Better and cheaper ways like GPS tracking of supply vehicles (as
successfully implemented in Tamil Nadu) would be a good option.
· Aadhaar cannot ensure the proper targeting of subsidy for it ensures only identity not eligibility.
|
Aadhaar does not need Parliament’s approval
|
The
executive cannot do what it pleases in relation to infringing
constitutional rights and protections for the reason that only
Parliament and legislatures have the power to make law on the subject.
If it does not need parliament’s approval why NIAI Bill was then mooted?
Why did Mr. Nilekani “waited’ for the parliament’s approval (as reported by media)
|
Aadhaar does not compromise Privacy
|
Application
of Driver’s Licence and Passport are significantly different from
Aadhaar. No agency has a large database comparable to UIDAI. None of
the details are expected to be universal and ubiquitous.
This
kind of data collection without an enabling law will surely run the
risk of data abuse, misuse and theft. Especially so in the absence of
Data Protection laws.
Involvement
of Private agencies with no experience or field knowledge or
sufficient staff would aggregate the risk for they subcontract the job
to others. The UIDAI doesn’t even know who is collecting what all
data from whome.
The so called ‘registrars’ what-all-information-they-want from the residents.
|
Biometric Technology is OK,
|
If biometric de-duplication is possible by current technology and equipments, why doesn’t the NIST of the
|
SCoF cherry picked UK ID project to criticize aadhaar.
|
It
is not the SCoF that cherry picked UK ID. Wipro Infosystems has in
their Vision Document for UID mentioned UK ID in 2006 in support of
AADHAAR. It is not the SCoF’s fault that the
|
AADHAAR is like Social security Number (SSN) of the
|
SSN
is completely different from aadhaar. It doesn’t collect biometrics
or any sensitive details. It just relates a number to a name.
The real comparison should have been between the Real I D Project 2005 abandoned by the
|
Aadhaar has no Security Issues
Parliamentary standing committee did not discuss the point
|
The committee has expressed concern over the implications of the Project Aadhaar on national security. The committee is “The
Committee are unable to understand the rationale of expanding the
scheme to persons who are not citizens, as this entails numerous
benefits proposed by the Government”[1]
“This will, they apprehend, make even illegal immigrants entitled for
an aadhaar number”. The committee especially is concerned about the
efficacy of introducer system on national security. As opined by many
the introducer system could result in many anti-national and
anti-social elements acquiring aadhaar numbers on false addresses.
The
committee has also noted that the Ministry of Home affairs has
expressed concern over the methodology data collection, reliability
and security of the data and the chances of fraud.
|
Aadhaar’s benefit does not outweigh costs
|
The
author lashes out at the SCoF for quoting the cost of the project as
150000crores. He should understand how UK ID project was found to be
economically unfeasible. The cost of the project is recurring in
nature. Every year enrollments have to be done for ‘new comers’. The
cost of equipments for a single enrollment centre is close to 3lakh
(as reported by The Hindu). Then consider the money required for
installing biometric readers in every point of service provision
(there are over 4.5lakh fair-price shops in
Do
the author believe that the 45000crore black money arise from ghost
identities? In fact Aadhaar cannot do anything to curb high level
fraud.
|
Failure of Bureaucracy cannot be held against AADHAAR
|
True. But this cannot be an excuse for launching a project without required formalities. The committee notes that “(a)
no committee has been constituted to study the financial implications
of the UID scheme; and (b) comparative costs of the aadhaar number
and various existing ID documents are also not available. The
Committee also note that Detailed Project Report (DPR) of the UID Scheme
has been done much later in April, 2011. The Committee thus
strongly disapprove of the hasty manner in which the UID scheme has
been approved. Unlike many other schemes / projects, no comprehensive
feasibility study, which ought to have been done before approving
such an expensive scheme, has been done involving all aspects of the
UID scheme including cost-benefit analysis, comparative costs of
aadhaar number and various forms of existing identity, financial
implications and prevention of identity theft, for example, using
hologram enabled ration card to eliminate fake and duplicate
beneficiaries.”[2] How
can a government approve a sum over Rs.3000 crores for a dubious
project, without a benefit analysis study and the approval of the
parliament?
Author
speaks about the Ernst & Young Project Report on UID but
cunningly hide the fact that the report was made two years after the
project report. How can you justify the fact that a project was
allowed to start without even a detailed project report?
|
The SCoF did not hear any experts supporting AADHAAR
|
Look at the list of persons appeared before the SCOF as witnesses:
UIDAI
1. Shri Nandan Nilekani, Chairman
2. Shri R.S. Sharma, Director-General
Indian Banks‟ Association (IBA)
1. Shri M.D. Mallya - Chairman
2. Dr. K. Ramakrishnan - Chief Executive
3. Shri M.R. Umarji - Chief Advisor-Legal
Confederation of Indian Industry (CII)
1. Mr Arun Duggal, Vice Chairman, International Asset Reconstruction Company (IARC) and Chairman Shriram Capital Limited
2. Mr Chirag Jain, Chief Operating Officer Canara HSBC Oriental Bank of Commerce Life Insurance Company Limited
3.
Mr Ravi Gandhi, VP, Corporate Regulatory Affairs Bharti Airtel 4. Mr
Rameesh Kailasam, Program Director IBM India Pvt. Limited
Enough?
|
SCoF raises irrelevant questions
|
To Mr. Shenoy the question whether Aadhaar is mandatory irrelevant. But
for the rural poor who faces risks of financial exclusion this is a
question of utmost importance. Comparing ration card with aadhaar is
insanity.
|







