‘The Inhuman Cult of Death’ and Dilemma of the Civil Rights Groups
“
A movement carried out in the name of India’s poor has, for all
practical purposes, degenerated into an inhuman cult of death” read the
editorial that The Hindu
carried on the day after the recent train sabotage allegedly by the
Maoists in Jhargran in West Midanpur district of West Bengal. The
heinous incident which took the lives of 141 people, pose challenging
questions before the civil society and those who sympathise with the
Maoist cause. With the opinions for stringent action against Maoists is
aired with little thought (say, about what the word stringent-action
means) we are in a dilemma. Strong back of the scene acts are on for
carrying forward the plans for military action against those who wage
‘war against our nation’. The home minister has called upon the Civil
Rights groups and the ‘intellectuals’ to condemn ‘the deliberate,
heartless violence’. And this could be a turning point in the nation’s
long history of fight against left-extremism.

The
recent surge in the Maoist violence has resulted in erosion of whatever
credibility or moral justification it had in the minds of the people of
the Indian mainland. In the last three months the Maoists targeted
rail-transport for 16 times and 150 innocent civilians got killed. If
CPI (Maoist) leader Muppala Laxman Rao apologised for the death of 14
adivasis when they blew up a bus in Warangal in 2002 his comrades in
2010 are trying to justify civilian causalities as unavoidable. It is
quite interesting to see global capitalism and left extremism using the
same phrase ‘collateral’ damage to cover their guilt. The Maoist
movement is gradually turning out to be another bloody game of futility.
The violent methods of the Maoists are condemned widely, Arundhathy Roy
recently described it as” absolutely inexcusable and cannot be
justified”. Dr. Binayak Sen, doctor and activist who was sentenced for 2
year imprisonment for alleged links with Maoists also expressed
disapproval and extreme contempt. PUCL after the Maoist attack on the
CRPF personnel came out with a statement condemning the Maoists. In a
statement it expressed that the PUCL “feels that no objectives could be
desirable that is sought to be achieved at the cost of human lives and
security. As is evident from the past experience, dialogue remains the
most potent and viable means of lasting peace”.
In
the meanwhile the story of train tragedy is turning upside down with
the Railway Minister Ms. Mamta Banerjee expressing doubts about a
conspiracy behind the incident and demanding a CBI enquiry. The People’s
Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), has denied any involvement in the
incident. The West Bengal state government was quick to blame it all on
the Maoists and the state has already started a CID inquiry into the
incident. The FIR filed by the Engine Driver, B K Das, made no mention
of the Maoists behind the accident. With so many theories swirling
around, a factual account of the incident is yet to come.
What
all are waiting for is the Government’s response. With lack of unity on
the counter-insurgency strategy within the cabinet already gone public
the government is under immense pressure to do something. The
earlier responses from the government was cautious as even the Union
Home Minister, P Chidambaram a staunch supporter of military action
preferring to shelve his usual spit of fire. While
condemning the incident we should be careful not to let this as a ruse
for witch-hunt. The people’s rights and freedoms cannot be compromised
in the name of security when the real reasons remain unattended. With
severe pressure from the authorities to show their allegiance to the
state the Civil rights Groups and the intellectuals are in a dilemma.
The danger of being branded as ‘anti-nationals’ shouldn’t prevent them
from carrying forward their present struggles for the poor. The
greater issues of exploitation by the Mining giants, land-grab and
oppression should not be forgotten. From the part of the government, it
should stop the use of civilian transport systems to carry armed forces.
Using rail and other civilian transport systems and also occupying
schools and other public places for setting up military camps would
expose the lives of innocent civilians to grave security threats.
Imminent personalities like K PS Gill, former Punjab DGP has pointed out
the need for addressing the basic issues like need for hospitals,
schools, proper sanitation, land and above all a right to live and die
in dignity. “Corruption built into the system which fails to deliver is
more destructive than criticism of Civil rights Groups” he said. Another
ex-DGP, K S Subramanian was also eloquent when he said, “Chidambaram
should read Arundhathi Roy rather than get inputs from the intelligence
agencies. He should talk to the Civil rights Groups”.
It
is well known that the main stream media is not impartial in its
reporting of the ‘Red-Terror’. More often than not they prefer to turn a
blind eye towards the atrocities committed by the Salwa Judum and
task forces. And independent reporting is factually impossible in
Maoist infected stats like Chattisgarh where there are laws like
Chattisgarh Public Safety Act in place. At the same time we cannot blame
it all on the government itself, but “both Chidambaram and Raman Singh
seem to be disciples of Bush. If you are not with us, you are against
us”, says Rama Chandra Guha, historian who was included in the fact
finding team send to Chattisgarh and was branded as a Maoist sympathizer
by the Special forces. That is where the trouble is; there is a
tendency to brand everyone who point out faults with the government as
anti-nationals. Sadly our mainstream media too takes such a stand. This
adds to the dilemma of the civil society. Yet lets hope the society
would stand up-to the challenge.



0 comments:
Post a Comment