
The massacre of 75 CRPF men by the Maoists in Chattisgarh came as shock to most of Indians. The loss of lives and grief and sorrow thereafter brings forth many questions about the country’s strategy to deal with extremism. Gandhiji’s
Recent Surge in ‘Maoist Violence’
On April 4,
2010 in Behrampur district of Orissa 9 jawans of Anti-Maoist Special
Operation Group (SGO) were killed and 8 seriously injured when 3 mini
buses carrying them blasted by remote controlled explosives set up by
the Maoists in Govind Pillai Ghat Road
at about 10am. The attack came just as the Government was preparing for
a major offensive against the Maoists. Reports say that the SGO men
were on their way to sanitise the Maoist-prone Govind Pillai Ghat Road so that CRPF personnel coming at Govind Pillai in Malkungiri district could move from there to Koraput.
On
April 6, 2010 came the most shocking of Maoist attacks in recent
history when 75 CRPF men were killed in in the Maoist attack in
Dantewada district of Chhattisgarh.
The troupe
was returning after a usual domination exercise in the region. AN
Armoured Personal Carrier was also destroyed when the Improvised
Explosive Device planted by the Maoists detonated.
Government response
The
government response to the incident was obvious with the Prime Minister
expressing” shock and grief'' over the loss of lives of security
personnel and Home Minister seeking detailed report from the authorities
at the same time Union Home Secretary G. K. Pillai reiterated the
government's resolve to carry out the fight against Naxals. “We will
give them a firmer reply”, said he.
Firmer reply; is it the same old clear, hold and build strategy?
What
does the government mean by this firmer reply? Whom they are going to
fight now? What will be the status of Operation Green Hunt now?
As I have mentioned already in another article in this blog, while
dealing with the issue of rebels and uprisings every nation and every
government it seems is learning nothing from the past. We cannot face insurgency with insanity! India ’s own history teaches us that extremism cannot be contained by mere
use of force. So far Mr. chidambaram’s dramatic pursuit of success and
high-sounding polemical attacks on the Maoists has resulted only in
jeopardizing the lives of hundreds of police and para-military personnel
who are ill-trained and ill-equipped to fight a battle in forest. Now
all that they do is protecting their own logistical line and camp
perimeters, as The Hindu put it on the editorial published on April 8th,
2010. Even the counting of causalities give Maoists a lead with only
294 Maoists killed as against 312 police and military personnel. Lesson
from the American experience in Vietnam , Iraq and Afghanistan and our own experience in Manipur, Andaman, Kashmir
and Nagaland should enough be for our policy-makers to understand that
in asymmetric wars, it need not be the strong who always win. But what
if we prefer not to fathom?
The
clear, hold and build strategy by which the government intends first to
clear the Maoists off the region and then hold it and build and bring
development to that region has failed miserably. Neither could the
government force the insurgents out nor could it bring development to
the region. Now that it is clear that it simply won’t work, then why
can’t the government accept the truth and seek alternatives?
Unclench our fist!
To
draw out a strategy to deal with extremism first we should shed our
prejudices and differentiate it from Terrorism. Terrorism is
unjustifiable, but as far as left extremism is considered there is some
sort of legitimacy for their demands. This we should accept. That is why
it has become a mass movement. Over one third of total numbers of
districts in
Now
that it is too late to bring development and reduce the Maoist
influence, the only way out is talk. Talk, talk and talk
unconditionally. Or at least a mutual ceasefire is possible. In an
exclusive interview to The Hindu, the spokesperson of CPI
(Maoist) has reiterated their stand they are ready to talk and is keen
on cessation of hostilities by both sides simultaneously. Now it is for
the government to act. And lets hope it would act prudently.




0 comments:
Post a Comment